Hanna rosin breastfeeding

Hanna Rosin is a contributing writer at The Atlantic and the author of. She is the co-host of the NPR podcast Invisibilia with Alix Spiegel. I agree with Rosin that people such as Dr. William Sears hype breastfeeding out of proportion to its proven benefits.

However, that doesn’t mean that. An angry but reasoned (and scientific!) critique of our obsession with breastfeeding.

Ellyn Satter, Registered Dietitian and Family Therapist. For more information on the author, please see her website. She covered politics and religion for the Washington Post for many years, and she has written for the New Yorker, The New York Times, GQ and The New Republic, among other publications. The provocative title is misleading, because as Rosin explained in an interview on NBC’s Today show on March 1 she isn’t against.

I am the co-host of the NPR show Invisibilia, about the invisible forces that shape human behavior. I was tricked into the job by my dear friend Alix Spiegel. We went to see a movie one night and then we have different versions of what happened next and hers is wrong.

If breastfeeding doesn’t automatically provide extra advantages and it does require women to go weeks without getting more than. In fact, she kind ofbreastfeeding.

Her problem is with the people who promote breastfeeding. When people say that breast-feeding is ‘free,’ it’s only free if a woman’s time is worth nothing. It is titled “The End of Men” and from hearing her speak it is obvious that she is opinionated andto provoke. A piece on the breastfeeding myth has sparked a debate about what makes a good mom.

Time does it with overgrown babies. This image of hot California mom (who looks a little like Kathryn Hahn) live- breast-feeding her almost 4-year. The general point will be familiar to the audience at. Rosin ’s personal opinions and observations regarding her breastfeeding experiences and appreciate her historical overview of the history of infant feeding.

I read her article and was amused and delighted with her writing. But unimpressed with her understanding regarding the science of human milk. By reading multiple scientific studies on the potential benefits of breastfeeding , she found that most were “inconsistent. Her argument is that breastfeeding isn’t nearly as beneficial as its made out to be. At best, kids get a few less tummy aches and colds.

At worst, breastfeeding is a tool that keeps us from true equality with men. Rosin finds that breastfeeding no longer works in her life and doesn’t want to be made to feel guilty about not breastfeeding her third child. Even so, Rosin ’s article still discusses Health at length, as do other news stories that do address women’s needs, reinforcing the idea that.

If this is your first experience with breastfeeding , changes in your breast milk may alarm you. I was left wondering whether she is actually reading the research she quotes, is simply selecting the research studies that support her points, or is just running off that at the mouth. Rosin was also featured on the Today Show on March with NBC News Chief Medical Editor Dr.

Although their discussion deplorably misrepresented the medical. Breastfeeding is a complex, physically. This is akin to saying that even though we know that eating better as a child leads to higher height, it should be dismissed because, well, aging has so much more to do with height than. If anything, she says, the medical literature. The longer the breastfeeding , the longer the exclusive breastfeeding , the less risk you will experience.

The author maintains that breastfeeding is inconvenience, represses women and the science that it is.